View All

Request A Quote

Business, Home & Auto Insurance

Serving Individuals, Families, and Businesses in OH, IN, KY and more.

For over 50 years, Sylvia A. Garrett Agency, LLC has delivered quality insurance solutions to individuals and businesses in Ohio and Nationwide, specializing in Business, Home and Auto insurance coverage. Our team of licensed, experienced and knowledgeable insurance professionals is committed to helping you find a policy that fits your needs. We focus on providing personalized attention and exceptional customer service to create an experience that’s difficult to find in today’s market. At Sylvia A. Garrett Agency, LLC, we’ll work with you to ensure that you and those you care about most are protected.

Meet Our Team

Sylvia Garrett
Sylvia Garrett

President, CEO

Kent Garrett
Kent Garrett

Chief Technology Officer

Michael Maurer
Michael Maurer

Operations Manager

Tamera Watkins
Tamera Watkins

Office Administrator

Nationwide logo
Progressive Insurance logo
CNA Surety Logo
Zurich Insurance logo
Foremost Insurance logo
United States Liability Insurance Group (USLI) Logo
Hagerty Insurance logo
Chubb logo
ACE Insured
American Strategic Insurance logo
Nationwide Private Client Logo
The Hartford logo
Hiscox Logo
Zurich Insurance logo
K&K Insurance Group Logo
Nationwide Independent
National General Insurance Logo
US Assure Logo
Dovetail Logo
Burns & Wilcox Logo
Dairyland Insurance
Lexington Insurance Company Logo
Gateway Specialty Insurance
Smart Choice
American Bankers Insurance Company of FL

Our Locations

Sylvia A. Garrett Agency, LLC
215 N. Front Street Columbus, OH 43215
Office: 614-249-2141
Fax: 614-249-4321